In
this Chapter Routman talks about how important it is to teach comprehension as
early as preschool/kindergarten. She expresses her concern about teaching
reading and emphasizing on fluency, automaticity, and word recall and not
giving comprehension the same importance during the early school years. She
says that has lead the children to focus on word recall not comprehension. That
reflects their summarized form of retelling a story instead of teaching
children to become critical thinkers which can allow the children to dig deeper
into the meaning of the character’s behaviors and plots of the literature they
read.
I look
at all these chapters and look at them from two points of views, the mom and
the teacher in me. My two boys are 3 and 5 years old. I have been reading to
them since before they were born. We have reading time every night and they
love to have books read to them and love to discuss them during and after story
time. The more the years go by the more detailed their questions, discussions
and retelling skills become. As a mom, I can vouch for the importance of early
literature comprehension.
Now,
as a teacher I can tell who is read to and likes to read at home. I get so much
out of my shared reading time. I can tell who is paying attention, who is
really listening, who can sit still for 5 to 15 minutes etc. 50% of my shared
reading time is used to read, but the other 50% I use to discuss and teach the
children how to become critical thinkers in order to increase their reading
comprehension. I ask a lot of questions while I read to them. I ask simple “right-there-in-the-text
questions, prediction questions, and in depth comprehension questions. Routman
says we need to ask and demonstrate how to ask questions that encourage
in-depth reading. This year I have seen how much my students have learned from
this strategy. Their questions and answers are now more significant in
comparison to the first months of school.
Their confidence in answering is shown in their faces and their verbal
responses. They compete to answer questions and give details to their answers
by stating facts previously read or discussed.
I
personally feel that the stronger the children’s literature comprehension is,
the more they will enjoy reading. I
loved this chapter. One of my favorite parts of this chapter is when Routman
advices us to “Use texts that are easy enough and meaningful enough to support comprehension.”
It is our responsibility as educators to guide children to choose a book they
will enjoy, a book that will allow them to grow as readers, critical thinkers,
and maybe even future authors.
I agree that we have (often without realizing it) spent so much time teaching students to read words, we have left out the comprehension aspect in many of our classrooms. I see it over and over when I am reading with my focus group. They are in the 4th grade and to hear them read, you would think they are good readers. However, they cannot retell or discuss the book on any comprehension level. Good reminder that reading is thinking . . . and we need to be teaching that right along with phonics!
ReplyDeleteYou have some great thoughts here, G! I especially love your last paragraph: "the stronger the children’s literature comprehension is, the more they will enjoy reading." We owe it to all our kids to use this high-quality children's lit and to delve into understanding it together!
ReplyDelete